When it comes to oral care, innovations abound—from advanced toothpastes to high-tech electric toothbrushes. Recently, tongue brushes paired with cleaning gels or liquids have gained popularity, promising fresher breath and a cleaner mouth. But as these products blur the line between everyday hygiene and targeted treatments, a pressing question arises: are tongue brushes with gel or liquid considered cosmetic products under EU regulations? This distinction is crucial—not just for manufacturers and retailers, but for consumers and compliance professionals seeking clarity in an ever-evolving market. In this article, we explore how cosmetic law defines such products, the factors influencing classification, and what it all means for your next product launch or purchase.
Table of Contents
Understanding the Cosmetic Product Definition Under EU Legislation
To determine whether a tongue brush combined with gel or liquid falls under the scope of a cosmetic product, it’s essential to analyze the product’s primary purpose and intended use as outlined in Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009. According to this regulation, a cosmetic product is defined as any substance or mixture intended to be placed in contact with the external parts of the human body (such as the skin, hair, nails, lips, and external genital organs) or with the teeth and the mucous membranes of the oral cavity, with a primary objective of cleaning, perfuming, changing appearance, protecting, keeping in good condition, or correcting body odours. When considering tongue brushes with a gel or liquid component, the function and claims made on the packaging or promotional materials are crucial to classification.
- Presents a cleaning effect: If the tongue gel or liquid is marketed for oral hygiene—such as reducing odour, cleaning the surface, or refreshing the mouth—it may meet the cosmetic product criteria.
- Contains active substances beyond cleaning: When oral care products include antibacterial or therapeutic claims (such as treating halitosis or killing specific germs), they may instead fall within the scope of medicinal products or medical devices.
- Packaging and usage instructions: The intended application method and warnings specified on the product packaging are essential for compliance assessment.
| Criteria | Cosmetic Product? |
|---|---|
| Cleaning/Refreshing Only | Yes |
| Therapeutic or Antibacterial Claims | No* |
| Marketing Targets Teeth or Oral Mucosa? | Conditional |
*Such products may require classification as medical devices or medicinal products under EU law.
How Gel and Liquid Tongue Brushes Are Classified in the Cosmetics Framework
Within the EU cosmetic regulatory landscape, products are classified based on their intended function and composition. Tongue brushes that incorporate gel or liquid preparations are evaluated on whether they are primarily designed to clean, refresh, or protect the oral cavity in a non-medicinal manner. If the gel or liquid component is marketed to cleanse the tongue, reduce bad breath, or enhance oral hygiene without therapeutic claims, these products could fall under the definition of a cosmetic according to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009. Important factors for classification include both the mode of action—mechanical versus chemical—and the consumer benefits outlined in the product’s promotion.
- Mechanical action: Cleaning by physical means (the brush structure)
- Chemical or cosmetic action: The impact of gel or liquid through cleansing, refreshing, or deodorizing effects
- Exclusion of medicinal claims: No prevention or treatment of oral diseases
| Classification Factor | Cosmetic Product? |
|---|---|
| Refreshes breath, cleans tongue | Yes |
| Claims to treat oral diseases | No |
| Contains antimicrobial agents for non-medicinal use | Yes (with CPSR) |
Should a gel or liquid tongue brush meet the criteria above, manufacturers must also ensure compliance through a Cosmetic Product Safety Report (CPSR) and proper EU notification via the Cosmetic Products Notification Portal (CPNP). Partnering with a laboratory specializing in cosmetic safety assessment is essential—not only for regulatory approval but to guarantee that all ingredients and product claims align with EU guidance. This approach ensures that your product is legally classified and positioned within the cosmetic framework, ready for confident sale across the EU.
Regulatory Implications for Manufacturers and Importers
When tongue brushes are sold together with an integrated gel or liquid, manufacturers and importers in the EU must carefully assess their regulatory status. According to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, the classification hinges on intended use: if the gel or liquid is designed primarily to clean, perfume, protect, or keep the oral cavity in good condition without treating or preventing disease, it’s likely considered a cosmetic product. This distinction is crucial, as it determines obligations such as labeling, safety assessments, and notification requirements on the Cosmetic Product Notification Portal (CPNP). Failure to comply with the correct classification could result in market withdrawal or legal penalties.
Key implications for manufacturers and importers include:
- Mandatory Cosmetic Product Safety Report (CPSR): Required before placing the product on the EU market.
- Appropriate Labeling: All ingredients and claims must follow EU cosmetic labeling rules.
- Documentation: Preparation and maintenance of a comprehensive Product Information File (PIF).
- Market Surveillance: Must be able to respond to competent authorities with compliance evidence.
| Obligation | Cosmetic Product | Medical Device |
|---|---|---|
| CPNP Notification | Yes | No |
| CPSR Required | Yes | No |
| CE Marking | No | Yes |
Expert Recommendations for Compliance and Product Safety
Ensuring regulatory compliance for tongue brushes combined with gel or liquid components requires a strategic approach tailored to their intended use and presentation. According to EU Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, products designed for cleaning, perfuming, changing appearance, or correcting body odours fall within the definition of cosmetic products. If the accompanying gel or liquid is formulated for oral hygiene or breath freshening—without therapeutic claims—it’s likely to be considered cosmetic. In contrast, gels with specific oral health or medicinal benefits may fall under medical device or medicinal product regulation, requiring stricter compliance pathways.
- Product Classification: Assess the gel’s ingredients and intended use to ensure correct product categorization.
- Documentation: Maintain a complete Cosmetic Product Safety Report (CPSR) and a Product Information File (PIF) for each variant.
- Labelling: All country-specific languages, ingredient lists in INCI format, and legal disclaimers must be present.
- Notification: Complete CPNP notification before market launch in the EU/EEA.
| Aspect | Requirement |
|---|---|
| CPSR | Mandatory for all gel/liquid components |
| Lab Testing | Stability & Microbiology checks required |
| Safety Labelling | Allergens and warnings visibly indicated |
